November 20, 2023
Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA): Proving Undue Hardship
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) requires employers with 15 or more employees to provide reasonable accommodations for the known limitations of a qualified applicant or employee due to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical condition. However, an employer may be exempt from this requirement if it can prove that no effective accommodation can be made without imposing undue hardship on its business.
The PWFA defines “undue hardship” as an action requiring significant difficulty or expense when considered in light of several specified factors. To prove undue hardship, an employer must perform an individualized assessment of current circumstances that show an accommodation would cause significant difficulty or expense.
Required Consideration Factors
Factors that must be considered when determining undue hardship include:
- The nature and cost of the accommodation needed;
- The overall financial resources of the facility;
- The number of employees at the facility;
- The effect on expenses and resources of the facility;
- The overall financial resources, size, number of employees, and, if applicable, the type and location of the employer’s overall facilities;
- The type of operation of the employer; and
- The accommodation’s impact on the operation of the facility.
Additional factors must be considered if the adjustment needed is a temporary suspension of an essential job function, which the PWFA may require under certain circumstances. These additional factors include the length of time the individual will be unable to perform the essential function, the nature and frequency of the essential function and several others.
No Generalized Conclusions
Proving undue hardship requires an individualized assessment of current circumstances and the consideration of several specified factors.
All Options Considered
Employers must consider all possible accommodations and all sources of available funding when assessing whether a particular accommodation would be too costly.
Not Undue Hardships
Certain accommodations—such as allowing a pregnant employee to carry water and take additional water, food and bathroom breaks—will virtually never be considered undue hardship under the PWFA.
Other Options Available
If one accommodation will cause undue hardship but a second one would be effective and not cause undue hardship, employers must provide the second accommodation.